← In the Chair
III

Negotiate

Common Ground

Two teams, one deal, and a scoresheet each side keeps hidden.

Time
~75 min
Team
Two teams, head to head
Format
Confidential briefs · hidden scoring
Level
No prereqs

What students do

Two teams negotiate a real deal: a café and its landlord, a shop and its supplier, two partners splitting a business. Each side gets a confidential brief, who they are, a points table for every possible outcome, and a walk-away. They meet, negotiate live, and reach a deal on every issue or walk. Then a facilitator scores both sides and reveals what each secretly wanted, and where value was won or wasted.

The skill it builds

Value creation. Finding the interest behind the position, growing the pie before splitting it, knowing your walk-away (BATNA), and reading a counterpart who is holding a hidden hand.

The one idea that makes it teach

Interests, not positions.

A beginner argues positions: '$2,600.' '$2,000.' That is a tug-of-war someone has to lose. Every deal here is built around an integrative trade, two issues the sides value oppositely, so the smart move is to give the thing that is cheap for you but valuable to them. The scoring is engineered so the team that finds the trade beats the team that only fights over the number.

  • Dig for the whyThe interest behind the demand is where the trade hides.
  • Grow, then splitCreate value first, claim it second. The order matters.
  • Know your floorA deal below your walk-away scores worse than no deal.
How it's scored

Fair, and the same shape every time.

Four criteria, 25% each, plus your points and the joint total posted for every pair.

Preparation25%

Did they name their interests, a target, and a walk-away before negotiating?

Value Creation25%

Did they uncover the trades instead of only fighting the obvious number?

Communication & Relationship25%

Clear, honest, respectful. Would the other side deal with them again?

Deal Quality25%

A deal above both walk-aways and near the top of the joint range, or a wise walk-away.

The worlds

Five deals, each with a hidden trade

The Corner Lease
A café and its landlord renew, trading rent against term and improvements.
Café + landlord
The Split
Two partners divide a business they built together.
Partnership
Three more deals
Group Rate, House Blend, and The Hire: a booking, a supplier, a key hire.
Supplier · hire

Bring the five to your classroom.

Decide · Investigate · Negotiate · Persuade · Respond

Request a sample packet and a run-through of any program. One class block is all it takes to see it work.